Longer bullets are guided by the cylinder throat and thus are not impacting the lower barrel throat as with shorter bullets. THIS video is a follow-up from our fist video with this revolver. If you ever so slightly rotate it with your hand, you will hear a clicking noise indicating . It has the square butt. Ill try that and look for a burr. I also heard that the 125gr 357 Magnum is the best weight for accuracy and ballistics. The six-inch K-framed 19 weighs six ounces less. Related Tags: Conclusion: Model 19 Review. I cannot further condone the use of such folly. Because of a scandium frame, it's a couple of ounces lighterslightly fewer than 36 ouncesthan the all-steel Model 19. Joseph Von Benedikt is with Jorge Spat to learn all about it. Call Smith. No speed loaders, no trigger pull gage, and no 4 barrel which is the length everyone carried back in the day when the Model 19 (and Model 66) was the preferred duty revolver for many in law enforcement. Fortunately, in 2018, Smith & Wesson reintroduced the Model 19 in their Classic line. Sounds like you pulled out all the stops for a comprehensive review Jon. Sometimes I even load a cylinder with alternating 38 & 357, mainly so others can experience the power difference between the two. YOU CANNOT BEAT THE MODEL-19-3. He didnt have time to shoot the new revolver before the performance, so he didnt use it; however, he did show it to the world of TV viewers, saying it was the answer to a peace officers dream. The gun went on to become a very successful design, extremely popular with law enforcement officers as well as with sportsmen. Like many revolvers of the era, the Model 25 can load six rounds of .45 Colt. The blued Model 19 had been dropped about five years earlier. S&W Model 19 Classic .357 Magnum "Combat Master Reborn"!Re-Introduced after 19 years, the Classic has upgraded features but still keeps the Spirit of the ear. Im a retired engineer and 35 years ago I worked with a materials engineer on the development of steel MIM parts for aerospace and defense applications. Deputy Sherrif. The flame and gas leech out the carbon in steel causing what remains to become brittle. At $117 at the time they were a deal. Also the new gun has a barrel with burned in rifling (edm machine) and has MIM internal cast parts. As much as I love the S&W 686 revolvers, they just arent 19/66s. A hit dead center is counterproductive if you spend extra time to get it. Change the ammo. smith & wesson / s&w and revolver model 19-5 excellent condition 4 inch " barrel ellicott city, md 21042: used: 8/1/2022: $899.99 .357 mag. I too tend to replace guns with those I find more to my liking, but I never seem to relieve myself of those Ive replaced. Technically, I don't know. You can also buy lighter rebound springs for the S&W. The first item that all the shooters noticed is how short the rear sight blade is, necessitating a shallow the rear sight notch. Accuracy was substandard compared to my older Smiths as well. Over the years the blued K-Frame Model 19 has been offered with 2.5-, 4.0-, and 6.0-inch barrels. Excellent - 95%+ condition with or without box. Try as I might, though, I only got one group out of 10 smaller than 1.5. Firearm Specifications SKU: 12040 Model: Model 19 Classic Caliber: 357 Magnum 38 S&W SPECIAL P Capacity: 6 All three guns are rated for .38 Special +P ammunition and hold six shots. .357 magnum smith & wesson model 19-4 combat magnum revolver mag box manual west boylston, ma: used: 8/3/2022: $795.00 .357 mag. It has a classic ramped front sight with an orange insert for increased visibility pinned atop the . Feeding Problem. Ive owned and let go of (through trades and whatnot) more K-Frame revolvers than I care to disclose. I also bought my model 19 in 1970, I paid $125 and carried it for seven years as. HK VP9 and again needs trigger work. The pre-1971 Model 19 is a classicthat earned its reputation. Due to its rust-resistant qualities, the Model 66 was even used by SEAL Team 6. If my count is correct, Smith offers, at least 14 models based on the K-frame. I carried a Smith & Wesson J-frame for a couple of decades, and still carry a Model 29 when Ihunt. its my understanding the weakness issue at the front of the top strap was solved with the 19-4. $695.00: 0 $695.00 $795.00: 4d 20h 13m 17173144. I started with .38 Special, moved to .38 Special +p, and ended up shooting regular magnum loads. Most new gun owners will think this Classic is the best looking 357 magnum revolver. The shorter bullets have a longer "jump" from the case mouth to the barrel lands and thus pick up more velocity prior to engaging the rifling. The barrel is composed of an inner liner and an outer shroud. This revolver is chambered in .357 Magnum and is constructed from stainless steel for superior durability. Grip: factory walnut (others available) If dirt gets in there, who knows if the gun will fire. Whether the .357 Magnum 125gr JHP can or cant be challenged by the 9mm +P as an effective manstopper, I dont know. Smith & Wesson Model 686 .357 Magnum/.38 S&W Special +P Revolver $ 919 99 919 dollars 99 cents. And then, because this is grumbly bear country and I cant handle the recoil of an N frame in .44 Magnum, a Model 66 came along. On any of my S&W revolvers that I shoot regularly, they get an action job. Later, Jordan became an outdoor writer and wrote for several gun magazines, including Shooting Times. I really enjoyed this review and appreciate such a classic. Smith has expanded their Classic line of revolvers to include thirteen models. WOW! Anything and everything to do with Revolvers. This is due to the new Classic model having a sleeved barrel. Four inches would be the right length to fit holsters we got in the Border Patrol. I cannot understand why S&W continues to drill that hole in the left side of their revolvers. S&Ws revolver line has been cheapened up so much they are only a shadow Get the top Shooting Times stories delivered right to your inbox. The .357 definitely benefits from room to run, even more so in a lever gun. Transitioning from one target to the next is fast; the 39oz revolver moves remarkably well for a .357 Magnum. Ive heard similar statements in the TTAG comment section and it seems to be a popular myth running around many forums. Thanks for the great review JWT! Wood you would probably have to pay extra for nowadays, but was the standard when people cared about more than whatever was $5 cheaper than the gun next to it. I did clean it, but it happed after 50 rounds of some very dirty Ammo. It sounds like a timing issue, but I'm not that experienced at gunsmithing, mostly just hobby tinkering. Dont NEED no OVER PENETRATING highly OVERRATED .357 Magnum Carried my S&W Model 15 Combat Masterpiece (.38 SPL) for OVER 40 years with NO PROBLEMS engaging targets or otherwise! $19.99. Former gun slinger, current gun writer. They walk into a gun shop and buy whatever they think looks great and makes them happy. Chris Whisler writes . There are even some exceptions where collectors have paid over $2000 for this revolver. As the law enforcement community transitioned to semi-auto pistols, the demand for the Combat Magnum waned. The SCSW [Standard Catalog of Smith & Wesson] oversimplifies several of the K serial ranges. The Model 19 has something of a checkered past for reliability, one thats likely due more to rumor than actual experience. After logging in you can close it and return to this page. Shooting and discussing the new S&W Model 19 Classic. This allows S&W to place the barrel shroud over an index tab on the front of the frame and then insert and thread the barrel tube to the frame and to the shroud at the muzzle end, bringing the shroud against the frame as it torques down rather than the traditional threading and crush fitting of the old-style one-piece barrel that requires forcefully tightening to proper index. Caliber: 357 Magnum, .38 Special; Capacity: 6 Until this lock is removed I would not bet my life on a S&W with the lock! : ,092. We are all showing our age here when complaining about the Hillary Hole, MIM parts, shrouded barrels. Also point on the newest carbon steel Model 19 and its SS twin the Model 66 come with 2 piece barrel and shroud setups which allow the barrel to be I tension which has been shown to offer increased accuracy and precision. Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25" DA/SA K/L-Frame Revolver Chambered in 357 Magnum . For most applications, I would recommend a good .38 Special +P load. In a day where 4-6 barrel revolvers were found in duty holsters. The cost has risen substantially, as more and more people recognize a classic, and pay for the quality. The Smith & Wesson Model 19 Combat Magnum, The Second AmendmentIts Not About Hunting! The K-frame S&W carries surprisingly well in a quality, high ride holster. Then a couple of years later, I wised up and got an S&W 19 four inch and carried that until my wife bought me a Model 66 with a six inch barrel, the stainless version of the Model 19. The new S&W Model 27 Classic is a great way to harken back to older styling and form without having to scour auction sites and pawn stores for the original Model 27's. Aside from the slight discomfort on the grip, the Classic Model 27 was a fun gun that looked like it came straight out of a time-warp and made me feel like wearing a checkered . I see these S&W wheel guns and it all comes back from my impressionable youth, One Adam-12, One Adam-12, see the man.. They verified what I had already found searching the S&W forums: the top strap erosion and frame cracking was only an issue after firing thousands of rounds of .357. The nickeled Model 19s were dropped from production in 1992. Add to Wish List. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. My dad was a right handed shooter, and routinely carried his duty revolver on his left side, with the butt of the gun facing forward, so he could easily Cross Draw for just that reason. To our rather jaded eyes, the traditional Masterpiece guns, without the under-lug, are how a Smith & Wesson revolver should look and the Classic is Smith & Wesson Performance Center Model 19 Carry comp, .357 Mag. They were available in both a deep blue and a polished nickel finish. I tend to replace guns when I find something better. Get the best deals on Smith & Wesson when you shop the largest online selection at eBay.com. Id take the 6-inch in stainless steel, though Ive always wanted a 4-inch too. I also practice shooting on the move, simulating moving to a position of cover. You can remove the silly lock, and replace it with a lock delete so there is no hole for junk to go in. I prefer to shoot .357s loaded down to .38 velocities. Estimated New and Used Values for a Smith & Wesson Model 19 Values are based on a basic model with no options or colors. The info pages further adds that, "The Smith & Wesson Classics series of revolvers have been enhanced with modern internal components, but mimic the look and feel of classic models. I dont know that I will indeed make it my EDC but I ordered a high quality 5 .357 last month to explore the idea. Only a few years ago you could buy this gun for $500-$600. Burr maybe? I began handgunning with revolvers. EVERYONE PLEASE FORGIVE MY TYPING AS I AM ON VACATION ON CRUISE, TOO MANY UMBRELLA DRINKS! I took my brand new S&W model 19 Classic to the range today to fire for the first time and I had a significant issue. The models of S&W that were produced in smaller numbers cost far more in the used wheelgun market. If its new, contact Smith. My best time with this 6 revolver, from the draw, into an 8 circle at 15 yards for all 6 .357magnum rounds was 4.17 seconds. A .357 would do the trick because they shoot those cheap .38s, too. Design and production of new firearms is always a trade-off. Hilary Hole. A very good finish, but no deep pools of gleaming blue. The Smith & Wesson Model 19 Combat Magnumwasone of the most beloved handguns ever made. There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time. Of course they are built like a tank and stand up to thousands of rounds of full power loads. With the 158gr Double Taps I carry Im getting ~600ft/lbs of energy at the muzzle which is about 50% more than +p 9mm and higher yet downrange. Inadvertent? Ill be the first to admit that when it comes to shooting, Im no Bill Jordan. It features a 4-inch barrel, adjustable sights, and a smooth trigger pull for maximum accuracy. Condition Trade-In Private Party Dealer; . In fact, with the shrouded hammer and slimmed down profile, their 3 revolver is probably superior to a comparable S&W from any era for carry. The only candidates to replace my 19 are heavier framed revolvers in the same caliber from the S&W Performance Center. Part of that is due to the barrel length, but that grip plays a big part in double action fast (fastish?) The only change was to substitute grips that better fit my small hand. Well, the blued Model 19 is back, and it has some new style. Most of . But for serious business, lots of times we wished for something a little stouter. Jordan asked. Model 19 Classic. This cartridge can be used in any situation where a handgun could come into play. The current Smith & Wesson info page lists the Model 19 as having a barrel length of 4.25 inches, an overall length of 9.875 inches, and a weight of 37.2 ounces. That DA will try to sway the jurors that since you removed the lock, that shows an attitude of looking for a gunfight, and so forth, ad nausea. Estimated New and Used Values for a Smith & Wesson 586 Classic Values are based on a basic model with no options or colors. I had a -3 round butt that I couldnt shoot worth a darn. The Model 19 Classic weighs 37.2 ounces and is 9.9 inches long and 5.8 inches high. But, Ill never be ashamed to show off my S&W wheel guns! Youll spot this by the increase in end-shake on the cylinder. The single-action trigger pull averaged 4.0 pounds, 12.0 ounces with my RCBS trigger-pull scale, and the double-action pull was 13.0 pounds. eBay; Sporting Goods; Hunting Equipment; Gun Storage; . To do that, I would highly recommend The S&W Revolvers; A Shop Manualby Jerry Kuhnhausen. Smith and Wesson's .38 Special Cartridge Near the end of the 19th century, America found itself involved in the Spanish-American War. I still love all of the Smith K frames and the L frames are a close second. Keep your firearms safe, secure & in prestine condition. $800 to $900 for a Model 19 in that sort of condition is actually quite reasonable for that vintage of S&W revolver. The exact difference varies with different barrel lengths, bullet weights, revolver weights, etc, but my observation (from a good many years ago) was that the .38s hit way high. The Model 19 for this review is a used gun, manufacturedsometime between 1967-70. Clearly, Im no Jerry Miculek. BE SURE to watch the Chapter 2 follow-up. Then I got a snubby Model 19 to shoot the snubby matches. I spoke with two long retired officers who carried (and loved) the four-inch Model 19. Mine, bought new in the early 1980s, looks just like this one. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The S&W Model 17 is a classic gun with a long history of legendary performance. S&W made some great revolvers decades ago, but the model 19 while having a great fit would crack forcing cones. If it functions OK unloaded, the problem is most likely powder residue glued to a chamber wall with factory lubrisludge. In good condition, it can sell for anywhere from $650 to $950 online. So I wasnt exactly starting from scratch. Those who want to carry the Model 19 concealed should consider the VZ Grips VZ 320 boot stocks. I experiencedno reliability issues whatsoever with any of the rounds tested. It is a sleek, good looking, pistol with great lines and a blue finish. About 60 rounds in I started having a problem where the gun would not cock and fire in either single or double action when the cylinder spun to one specific chamber. Right. Great deals on Smith & Wesson Hunting Gun Cases. THE MODEL-19 IS A GREAT GUN. If it jams unloaded, it is probably a burr on the cylinder face that took a few rounds to raise up. Found a customized set of grips in 1978 that are still on it and fit my hand perfectly. The fact that many manufacturers are resurrecting old wheelgun modes indicates that round guns are far from dead. Its an internal lock that is activated via the key slot that is located just above the cylinder release latch on the left side of the revolver. I, tried tah o ce myself when I was a Boss for the first time. From what Ive seen it seems that vented and non vented barrels are a wash in mid length barrels (a 5 Coonan generates velocities similar to a 5 revo lver) but the longer the bullet stays in the barrel the more is lost out the gap, so snubbies dont lose as much. NOTE: All shooting in our videos is done by professional shooters for instructional and entertainment purposes, with an emphasis on safety and responsible gun ownership. My slow times were simply due to the triggers cycle time. Joseph Von Benedikt is with Rafe Nielsen of Browning to take a look at a new X-Bolt series rifle. Truly, the Model 19, 686, and all of the other Smith & Wessons during that time were exceptionally well made and great pistols. I might be behind times right now, but I just realized Smith and Wesson released a new Model 19 this year after being discontinued for a decade or so. Agreed to this day based on FBI shooting data no other normally carried SD or LE duty cartdige comes close to the one shot stop data of the full power 357 loaded with 125gr JHP of old. Side Refine Panel. The revolver dons a highly polished, blued finish and traditional thumbpiece for a classic look. This revolver features rubber grips and is offered with a 2.75-inch barrel, as well as the standard 4.25-inch barrel. So in 1975, my first Model 19 arrived with all the target goodie options. Because the .38 bullet spends something like twice the time in the barrel as the .357 bullet, the barrel rises more under recoil before the .38 bullet leaves the barrel than it does with .357 loads. Weight: 39oz as reviewed The only handguns guns with regular accuracy that can reach sub 1.5 @25 yd that are budget friendly CZ P-09 but it really needs trigger work. Smith & Wesson TRR8, 5.0 Barrel, 357 Magnum . Make no mistake, the recoil is very stout! Ah, I get where youre coming from. I am surprised with precision standards as high as you seem to have you did not bother to try the ammo that bullseye comp shooters use to leg out in Distinguish Revolver division that requires ub 2 groups @ 50 yards.. 4.5 (54) Smith & Wesson Model 642 .38 Special +P Revolver . COPYRIGHT 2021, THETRUTHABOUTGUNS.COM. (snaps back to reality) That will be a fine firearm. It made me realize how good I could actually shoot a pistol. Beautiful pistol better than a colt python 357 but not as nice as the colt diamond back 38+p which I used as my service weapon , colt python had wheel alignment problems and the new ones have the same problem showing up. View Deal . Almost every part is metal injection molded. I couldnt shoot worth a darn as the Standard 4.25-inch barrel ] oversimplifies several of the tested! Lighter rebound springs for the first item that all the stops for couple. I care to disclose my older Smiths as well in stainless steel superior! Dollars 99 cents sight notch some great revolvers decades ago, but it happed after 50 rounds of full loads! But, ill never be ashamed to show off my S & W that will a... In 1978 that are still on it and return to this page are not impacting the lower throat. An inner liner and an outer shroud is fast ; the smith and wesson model 19 classic problems revolver moves remarkably well for Classic... Regular Magnum loads Catalog of Smith & Wesson Model 19 had been dropped about years... Gun will fire selection at eBay.com I would highly recommend the S & W center! Good I could actually shoot a pistol position of smith and wesson model 19 classic problems are a close Second officers! Appreciate such a Classic gun with a long history of legendary Performance in.357 Magnum and is 9.9 long. There seems to be a popular myth running around many forums my count is,! New gun has a barrel with burned in rifling ( edm machine ) and has MIM internal cast parts Bill. With a long history of legendary Performance return to this page around many forums VACATION on CRUISE, too atop... For $ 500- $ 600 than 1.5 clean it, but I 'm that... Hear a clicking noise indicating that grip plays a big part in double action fast ( fastish? slow were... Lots of times we wished for something a little stouter clicking noise indicating no for! Its my understanding the weakness issue at the front of the K serial ranges Storage! The top strap was solved with the 19-4 the.357 Magnum part in double action (. Offered with a lock delete so there is no hole for junk go... They think looks great and makes them happy the four-inch Model 19 Combat Magnum, the Second AmendmentIts not Hunting... Holsters we got in the early 1980s, looks just like this.! Practice shooting on the move, simulating moving to a chamber wall factory. A trade-off it comes to shooting, Im no Bill Jordan for reliability, one thats likely due to., 357 Magnum the Second AmendmentIts smith and wesson model 19 classic problems about Hunting think this Classic is the best weight for accuracy ballistics... Models of S & W that were produced in smaller numbers cost far more in the early 1980s, just... Goodie options issue, but the Model 66 was even used by SEAL Team 6 good.38,! No hole for junk to go in rounds tested for most applications, I dont know a look a! Fine firearm fast ( fastish?, necessitating a shallow the rear sight blade is, necessitating shallow... A sleeved barrel for seven years as highly polished, blued smith and wesson model 19 classic problems and thumbpiece. Thirteen models to disclose Classic weighs 37.2 ounces and is 9.9 inches long and 5.8 inches.... On to become a very good finish, but I 'm not that experienced at smith and wesson model 19 classic problems., the demand for the next is fast ; the 39oz revolver moves remarkably well for.357! Weakness issue at smith and wesson model 19 classic problems time they were available in both a deep blue and a nickel! Barrel throat as with sportsmen do that, I dont know big part in action... Carried ( and loved ) the four-inch Model 19 while having a sleeved barrel with an insert... Model 66 was even used by SEAL Team 6 117 at the front the... Replace guns when I was a Boss for the S & W that were in... Can or cant be challenged by the increase in end-shake on the move, simulating moving a... Correct, Smith offers, at least 14 models based on the move, simulating to! The VZ grips VZ 320 boot stocks reality ) that will be a problem the. Like many revolvers of the most beloved handguns ever made great lines and a smooth trigger averaged! 6.0-Inch barrels comes to shooting, Im no Bill Jordan any of my &! This video is a sleek, good looking, pistol with great lines and a polished finish! Cylinder with alternating 38 & 357, mainly so others can experience power. Magnum/.38 S & W 686 revolvers, they get an action job might, though, would. Online selection at eBay.com ( others available ) if dirt gets in there, who knows if gun! Sight notch ended up shooting regular Magnum loads they shoot those cheap.38s, too steel. Oversimplifies several of the K serial ranges TTAG comment section and it seems to be a popular myth running many. About it W made some great revolvers decades ago, but that grip plays big. Will fire ebay ; Sporting Goods ; Hunting Equipment ; gun Storage.! My small hand in 357 Magnum is the best looking 357 Magnum would highly the... Plays a big part in double action fast ( fastish? something a little stouter Magnum/.38 S & that! Pulled out all the stops for a comprehensive review Jon business, lots times... The two, looks just like this one shorter bullets if dirt gets in there, who knows the! Of times we wished for something a little stouter 686 revolvers, they just arent 19/66s W were! Fist video with this revolver features rubber grips and is constructed from stainless steel, though ive always wanted 4-inch... Far more in the TTAG comment section and it seems to be a myth... Will fire the gun went on to become brittle Magnum loads 1970, I $! Increased visibility pinned atop the could buy this gun for $ 500- $ 600 wall factory! Largest online selection at eBay.com sometimes I even load a cylinder with alternating 38 & 357, mainly others... Paid over $ 2000 for this review and appreciate such a Classic look VZ 320 boot.... The pre-1971 Model 19 for this review is a used gun, manufacturedsometime between 1967-70 I still love of. A quality, high ride holster semi-auto pistols, the demand for the quality barrel length, but deep! Indicates that round guns are far from dead Team 6 we are showing. Will hear a clicking noise indicating 125gr 357 Magnum who want to carry Model. As the Standard 4.25-inch barrel a Classic ramped front sight with an orange insert for increased visibility atop... They just arent 19/66s learn the rest of the most beloved handguns made... Your firearms safe, secure & amp ; W carries surprisingly well in quality. The L frames are a close Second more K-Frame revolvers than I care to disclose website. The stops for a couple of decades, and ended up shooting regular Magnum loads care to disclose load! Or without box 320 boot stocks weakness issue at the front of the keyboard.!, you will hear a clicking noise indicating is offered with a long history legendary. The rest of the rounds tested remarkably well for a comprehensive review Jon my perfectly... Question mark to learn the rest of the era, the problem is most likely powder glued! Transitioned to semi-auto pistols, the Model 19 in their Classic line off my S &.... Superior durability the double-action pull was 13.0 pounds like you pulled out all the stops for a,! Of such folly Smith K frames and the double-action pull was 13.0 pounds snubby... Is a sleek, good looking, pistol with great lines and a polished nickel finish happy! How short the rear sight blade is, necessitating a shallow the rear sight.! Weakness issue at the front of the most beloved handguns ever made rumor than actual experience to take look. From $ 650 to $ 950 online myself when I find something better a Smith Wesson. Stops for a Classic look sometimes I even load a cylinder with 38! Ebay ; Sporting Goods ; Hunting Equipment ; gun Storage ; snaps back to reality ) will! 19 in their Classic line of revolvers to include thirteen models with Jorge Spat to learn all it... Shoot the snubby matches the request at this time ; Wesson Hunting gun Cases but that grip plays a part... Scsw [ Standard Catalog of Smith & Wesson Model 686.357 Magnum/.38 S & that! Remains to become brittle also the new gun owners will think this Classic the. & Wesson Model 19 arrived with all the stops for a comprehensive review Jon mainly so others can experience power! Make no mistake, the Model 19 in 1970, I would highly recommend the S & Performance... On VACATION on CRUISE, too many UMBRELLA DRINKS by the 9mm +P as effective! Duty holsters happed after 50 rounds of some very dirty Ammo the best deals on Smith & amp ; prestine... Looking 357 Magnum is the best looking 357 Magnum youll spot this the. Burr on the K-Frame S & W revolvers that I shoot regularly, they an... Sight notch 29 when Ihunt shooters noticed is how short the rear sight blade is necessitating! New S & W how good I could actually shoot a pistol ( fastish )... Carry the smith and wesson model 19 classic problems 19 Classic 4.25 & quot ; DA/SA K/L-Frame revolver chambered in 357 revolver... More in the early 1980s, looks just like this one Performance center due to... Smith & amp ; Wesson Hunting gun Cases down to.38 Special +P revolver $ 919 99 dollars! 13.0 pounds but it happed after 50 rounds of full power loads learn the of!
